Salvatore Chirumbolo and Paolo Bellavite
âHomeopathy: Ex nihilo fit nihilâ??
Homeopathy, 2010, 99 (3), 226-227

We recently came across an article by Prof. M. Pandolfi in the European Journal of Internal Medicine.1 This contribution reads like a letter to the editor but appears as a âspecial articleâ, a type of article not included in the journalâs editorial submission checklist. It is not a scientific paper, since it does not report methods or any results. It would have been more honest to publish it as an editorial.Some years ago we chanced upon Titus Lucretius Caroâs De Rerum Natura.2 Lucretius (98â55 BC.) was a Roman philosopher known for his naturalistic view. We tend to agree with Pandolfi when he (wrongly) quotes Lucretius as saying ex nihilo fit nihil, this quotation (correctly ex nihilo nihil fit) should have been attributed to René Descartes in his Principia Philosophiae. Lucretiusâs concept of nothingness was not an âemptyâ non-being. He said ânil igitur fieri de nilo posse fatendumst, semine quando opus est rebus quo quaeque creatae aeris in teneras possint proferrier aurasâ? (One must admit that nothing can rise from nothingness, as things need a seed, from which each thing, once generated, can spread out in the light breath of airâ¦)2, further on, he wondered about the order of cosmos (neque forte deum nobis immense potestas sit, vario motu quae candida sidera versit) (and, by chance, isnât that a great divine power turning shining stars in their movings shows himself to all of us?)2 T.C. Lucretius, De rerum natura. In: G.B. Conte, Editor, RCS Publisher, Milan, Italy (1990) L. Canali trad..2.